Abigail wants the election to end.

By now, most people have either seen or heard about the young girl who broke down crying because she was so sick of hearing about the presidential election.[1]  Indeed, if we track social media responses we find that many adults agree with the youngster and they are sick of hearing from and about both President Obama and Mitt Romney.  Many of these reactions are due to the negative and false statements that seem inherent in modern political campaigns.

There are organizations, the Center for Responsive Politics to name one, that try to keep politicians honest by fact checking statements and publicizing the results.  It seems that the states have also developed a method—a legal method—to achieve the same end.  The Wall Street Journal Blog today[2] reports that several states have criminal laws that sanction false campaign speech—at least false speech waged at your opponent.  Prosecutions are rare.  Still, it does beg a free speech question.  Last term in US v. Alvarez (No. 11-210) the Supreme Court determined that the Stolen Valor Act was unconstitutional.  Essentially, lying about winning a military award, even if you do so to gain office, is protected speech.

Rick Hasen, the Wall Street Journal Blog reports, makes the argument that Alvarez likely voids state laws regarding false campaign speech.[3]  And I agree that it is likely that Alvarez along with the available more narrow remedies for libel and slander make the laws unconstitutional.  But there is another precedent that also leads to the same result and certainly does so in conjunction with Alvarez.  In Republican Party of Minnesota v. White (563 US 756 (2002)), the Supreme Court held that Minnesota’s “announce clause” was an unconstitutional burden on the speech and prohibited speech based upon its content.  Minnesota tried to level the playing field for incumbent judges and their opposition.  Since the judges were restricted in terms of discussing issues or announcing position due to the canon of judicial conduct, challengers would face the same restrictions.  The state’s interest in impartiality was not sufficient to withstand strict scrutiny.

The false campaign speech laws are similar to the  ‘announce clause’ from White.  They criminalize speech based upon its content.  In White, Scalia agreed with the Court of Appeals that the ban “burdens a category of speech that is “at the core of our First Amendment freedoms”—speech about the qualifications of candidates for public office.”

Combine the Republican Party of Minnesota v. White with US v. Alvarez and there seems to be a constitutional right to lie on the campaign trail about your own qualifications and your opponents.  Perhaps we can blame the Supreme Court[4], at least partially, for Abigail’s tears and total toddler meltdown.

Advertisements

1 Comment

Filed under Freedom of Speech, Assembly, and Association, Voting and Representation

One response to “Abigail wants the election to end.

  1. Jo Rae Perkins

    Problem is, the voters say they want to hear the truth, when politicians speak the truth, the people don’t want to face the realities. They want to live in their own little world. They say they don’t like the negative ads, but vote based upon the negative ads – many don’t bother to conduct their independent research. After all, the candidate would not lie because someone will fact check them and the truth would get out. By the time the statements are fact checked, voters and candidates have already moved onto the next topic… Would be great if candidates and their supporters stopped using half facts/truths or bald face lies. Learn to stand on your own merit.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s